*Ellie Roser
The Supreme Court of Maryland determined that allowing the early canvassing of absentee ballots due to emergency circumstances is a judicial function. In re Emergency Remedy by the Md. State Bd. of Elections, 292 A.3d 319 (Md. 2023).
I. Introduction
In In re Emergency Remedy by the Md. State Bd. of Elections, the Supreme Court of Maryland evaluated whether its judicial function includes the power to permit early canvassing of absentee ballots as a result of emergency circumstances.[1] Judicial regulation of absentee ballot canvassing goes to the heart of present-day skepticism in the United States election process.[2] In the wake of the COVID-19 Pandemic, over 97% of voting occurred via absentee ballots during the 2020 election cycle.[3] The State Board of Elections (“State Board”) argued before the court that the rise of absentee voting in the 2020 election, combined with the Maryland General Assembly’s intent to make absentee voting more accessible, required lifting certain restraints on early canvassing of ballots.[4] The State Board asserted that a judicial remedy would reduce strain on local boards and allow the State Board to meet statutory deadlines necessary to finalize election results.[5] The court analyzed the circuit court’s authority under the separation of powers principle to determine if granting such an electoral remedy qualified as a judicial function.[6] The court then provided a subsequent analysis of the meaning of emergency circumstances that would permit a suspension of the Election Law.[7] The court concluded that granting an electoral remedy fell within its judicial function, and determined the imminent wave of absentee ballots was an emergency circumstance.[8]
Continue reading “Highest Case Note from Write-On 2024: In re Emergency Remedy by the Md. State Bd. of Elections, 292 A.3d 319 (Md. 2023).”