*Rebecca Odelius
I. Introduction
While the rest of America debated if and how reparations should be given for the injustices of slavery and segregation,[1] the state of California took legislative action to atone for the mistreatment of one Black couple whose land the state wrongfully took through eminent domain[2] in 1924.[3] In an unprecedented move, California’s legislators returned a large piece of land, known as “Bruce’s Beach,”[4] located in the prestigious Manhattan Beach, California, to the descendants of its rightful owners.[5] Because there is no statute in the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) specifically addressing land reparations,[6] the tax implications for Bruce’s Beach remain unclear.
II. The Story of Bruce’s Beach
In 1912, Willa and Charles Bruce purchased a California beachfront property and converted the land into “the first west coast resort for Black people.”[7] Despite forceful attempts by local Klan members to run the Bruces off Bruce’s Beach,[8] the resort remained popular and successful with other Black residents and visitors.[9] However, in 1924, “the Manhattan Beach Board of Trustees voted to condemn Bruce’s Beach and the surrounding land through the power of eminent domain under the ostensible purpose of building a park.”[10] The Board of Trustees tore down the resort and “enacted ordinances precluding the opening of any new beach resort in order to prevent the Bruces from relocating their business elsewhere in the city.”[11] Bruce’s Beach sat dormant until 1948, when the City Council transferred it to the state.[12] The state eventually transferred Bruce’s Beach to the county in 1995, but the transfer included strict limitations on further transfers and land use.[13]
Continue reading “Gross Income and Land Reparations: The Tax Implications for Bruce’s Beach”