*Sarah Steinberg
On July 20, 2018, the City of Baltimore filed a lawsuit in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City against twenty-six fossil fuel companies (collectively, the “defendants”).[1] The City contends that these energy companies should pay the costs associated with climate change in Baltimore.[2] The City alleged that the oil companies engaged in fraud, deception, denial, and disinformation, causing irreparable damage to Baltimore.[3]
II. The Jurisdictional Battle
Immediately after the filing of the complaint, two of the defendants moved for removal to federal court, commencing an aggressive jurisdictional battle between the parties.[4] The oil companies’ liability may hinge on whether a federal or state court hears the case. The defendants are fighting for a federal court since federal law treats common law nuisance more favorably than state law.[5] In American Electric Power v. Connecticut, the Supreme Court held the Clean Air Act, as well as Environmental Protection Agency action, authorized by the Clean Air Act displaces federal common law public nuisance claims against carbon-dioxide emitters.[6] This holding illustrates that the Clean Air Act provides a means to seek limits on companies’ emissions which would be the same relief the plaintiffs are seeking by invoking federal common law.[7] Precedent dictates that judges cannot set limits on greenhouse gas emissions in place of the Clean Air Act which permits the Environmental Protection Agency to set the same limits.[8] Therefore, if the City’s case is removed to federal court, then the case will likely be dismissed.[9] If the matter progresses in federal court and defendants lose, then the defendants could access the conservative-leaning United States Supreme Court, where they would face a favorable bench.[10] In contrast, the City assumes state court would prove a friendlier venue since Maryland elected judges would hear the matter.[11]
Continue reading “The Future of Climate Change Liability: A Jurisdictional Battle”